267-856-7500
Skip to main content
Pick Our Brains...
< All Topics
Print

The “Butts in Seats” Blueprint: How to Sell Out Your Theater

Posted
Updated

By Tracy Byrne of Gypsy Stage Company & TLC Scripts

The Theatre Marketing Truth-Bomb: A sell-out doesn’t happen in the box office; it happens in the community. Most theaters fail because they “announce” a show instead of “building a movement.” This is the exact 6-Pillar system I used to consistently fill a 200-seat house to capacity.

Pillar 1: The “Digital Footwork” (Local Calendars)

Don’t wait for people to find your website. Go where they are already looking for “things to do.”

  • The Local Search: Every county has a Calendar style website for the geographical area.  For us here in Bucks County PA, it’s BucksCountyAlive.com. Search Google for [Your County] + "event calendar" or [City Name] + "things to do".  Then list each date of your show as a free listing and at least one of those dates as a paid listing.  It’s usually pretty cheap to do so and gives you enhancements like bolded listings and appearing first, etc.

  • The Evvnt Multiplier: Use Evvnt.com. You can list your events to their calendar for free and it will show up with them and I think up to 1-3 other calendar sites.  BUT, a single $70 investment pushes your listing to 70+ local news and calendar sites, like USA Today local affiliates, simultaneously. It’s the best “time-for-money” trade in theatre marketing.

  • The Eventbrite Billboard: Even if you use another ticketing system, list 10-15 tickets on Eventbrite. Why? Because Eventbrite is a massive search engine. Use the description to say: “Sold out here? Visit our website for remaining seats!” It’s a free billboard in a high-traffic area.  Keep in mind, the percentage that Eventbrite keeps on each ticket sale is rather high, it’s why I didn’t use it for my full ticket sales package.

Pillar 2: The Social Media “Drip & Hustle”

  • The Paid Drip: Instead of a one-time “boost,” set a $150–$200 budget on Facebook to “drip” over the 7 days prior to opening night. This keeps you top-of-mind exactly when people are deciding their weekend plans.  Choose a 50-mile radius of your theatre’s location and the appropriate age group for your show, for us it was usually 18+, save for Christmas shows.  To do this, make your post to your page or group, then click the “Boost Post” button that shows up at the bottom of it and follow the prompts.

  • The Manual Share (The Secret Sauce): On Facebook, join every local “Community,” “Moms,” and “Theatre Lovers” group that allows you to post events within a 30-mile radius. Then, use your phone to share your page’s post directly into these groups. Why not your desktop PC?  Because the phone tools make it faster and easier to do this, fewer steps.  This is a bit time-consuming, but this “manual hustle” often generates more reach than paid ads, the difference is between 10’s of views vs. 10,000 views.

Pillar 3: Google “Near Me” Optimization

When someone searches “Live Theatre near me,” you need to be the first result.

  • Update your Google Business Profile with your specific show dates, photos, and ticket links. Google prioritizes “Active” profiles with upcoming events.

Pillar 4: The High-Conversion Poster & Program

  • The 3-Second Rule: Your poster must communicate the Title, the Vibe, and the Ticket URL in 3 seconds from 10 feet away.

  • The QR + URL Combo: Always include a QR code for the savvy, but always include a short, readable URL (e.g., theatre.com/tickets) for those who aren’t digitally savvy or have tech glitches.

  • OK, I have a poster but where do I use it you may ask? Well…
    • Go around to local businesses with your posters and flyers and negotiate they display your posters and flyers in their store/lobby and in exchange, they can put a free ad into your program and/or on your website, perhaps in your pre-show slide show where you show all your ads while your audience waits for the show to begin.
    • Have a row of posters displayed in your lobby, like movie theatres do, of your upcoming shows.

Let’s delve a little deeper into this one as this is a lost art IMHO.

1. High “Dwell Time” Locations (The Captive Audience)

These are places where people are bored and looking for a distraction.

  • Laundromats & Coffee Shops: People are literally waiting. Your poster becomes their reading material.

  • Waiting Rooms: Doctors, dentists, and even car repair shops. (Offer them a couple of “Comp” tickets for the staff in exchange for a permanent spot on their community board).

  • Barber Shops & Salons: People sit in chairs for 30–60 minutes. Ask the owner if you can put a small “Table Tent” version of your poster at each station.

  • Restaurants (The Restroom “Stall Talk”): It sounds funny, but a clean, framed poster on the back of a restroom door is one of the highest-viewed spots in any building.

2. High “Foot Traffic” Locations (The Visibility Play)

These are for brand awareness and “Near Me” reinforcement.

  • Libraries & Community Centers: They usually have a dedicated “Arts” board. This gives your show a “stamp of approval” from the town.

  • Grocery Store Vestibules: Many have a community bulletin board near the exit. Use bright colors here to stand out from the “Lost Dog” flyers.

  • Post Offices: If they have a public board, it’s a goldmine. Everyone in town goes there eventually.

  • Gyms & Yoga Studios: Great for modern plays or high-energy musicals.

3. Your Own “Interactive” Lobby Wall

Since you have a digital print shop, you can do what most theatres can’t:

  • The “Coming Soon” Gallery: Instead of just one poster, have a dedicated wall with large 24×36 versions of the next three shows.

  • The “Photo Op” Poster: Create a version of your poster with a “hole” or a space where people can stand and take a selfie. If they post it to Instagram, it’s a free digital ad.

  • The Signature Poster: After a show, have the cast sign a poster and hang it in the lobby. It builds that “Family” atmosphere you mentioned where the audience feels connected to the actors.

4. The “Exchange” Strategy (Your Idea, Beefed Up)

  • The Window Trade: “You put my poster in your front window, I put your 1/4 page ad in my program.”

  • The “Golden Ticket” Drop: Leave a stack of “Rack Cards” (smaller, 4×9 versions of your poster) at the checkout counter of local boutiques or toy stores.

  • The Sandwich Board: If your theatre is in a walkable area, put an A-frame sign on the sidewalk 2 hours before curtain. It catches the “What should we do tonight?” crowd.

The “Truth-Bomb” Execution Tip:

When you send your “poster run” team out, tell them to bring Washi Tape or Painter’s Tape. It doesn’t ruin the shop owner’s paint or glass, which makes them much more likely to say “Yes” next time, and you’re sure the poster goes up because your team put them up themselves.  Leaving it up to the busy shop staff or owner means the poster will more likely collect dust in a corner or on a desk while they “get around to it”.

Pillar 5: The “Intermission Raffle” (The List Builder)

This is how you turn a one-time attendee into a lifetime fan.

  • The Physical Slip: Hand out a paper raffle ticket to every person at check-in. Ask for their Name, Email, and Zip Code on the raffle ticket.

    • Tell them you’ll be doing a raffle drawing at intermission and giving away 2 free tickets to any up-coming show of the winner’s choosing.  These tickets need to be numbered, leaving a numbered half with the audience member.

  • The Live Drawing: Do the drawing at Intermission. Give away 2 tickets to a future show.

  • Why Physical? The “splash” of a physical drawing on stage builds excitement and trust that a digital “join our list” pop-up never will.  Plus, it gives you another opportunity to “play” with your audience which turns them into part of the family, not just unknown faces in a crowd.  This creates supporters and advocates that keep coming back show, after show, after show.

  • The Result: You walk away from every show with a stack of verified local leads for your email list, your audience had fun and got to know you, and some audience members got a prize and feel really good about themselves … win-win-win!

Pillar 6: The “Family” Connection

Theatre is personal. Be playful and engaging with your audience before the show, at intermission, and after.

  • When the audience feels like they are “part of the family,” they don’t just buy a ticket; they become your street team.

The Pre-Launch Checklist (The “Everywhere” List)

Keep a master spreadsheet of every group, calendar, and news site you post to. If it’s not on the list, it didn’t happen.  Use it to make sure you don’t forget anything when you’re moving on to the marketing for the next show.

Tags:
Table of Contents