How to Choose the Right Script for Your Next Season

by tracyrenee | Jan 26, 2026 | News, Season Planning

Selecting a script for your next theatre season can feel like standing in front of an overflowing buffet. So many choices, so many flavors. But a successful season isn’t just about finding a good play. It is about finding the right play for your audience, your cast, and your budget.

Here is a practical guide to help you cut through the clutter and make a confident choice.

1. Know Your Audience.

Who fills your seats? Are they looking for laugh-out-loud comedies or thought-provoking dramas? Do they prefer family friendly musicals or gritty, realistic plays? Understanding your audience’s preferences is the first step to building a loyal following and selling tickets. Don’t program for yourself, program for them.

2. Assess Your Talent Pool.

Be honest about the actors who typically audition. If you consistently have a strong ensemble of women, consider Female-Forward Plays. If your pool is often smaller, focused, and agile, exploring Small Cast Plays can lead to incredibly powerful productions without the stress of finding 20 actors. Conversely, if you have a vibrant youth program or a deep bench of experienced performers, a Large Cast Production might be perfect.

3. Crunch the Numbers.

Beyond royalties, consider the full production budget. A complex musical will demand more for sets, costumes, and musicians than a simple play. Remember that low cost play scripts can free up funds for other production elements, enhancing the overall audience experience. Our transparent theatre royalties (4% for plays, 6% for musicals) make it easy to budget from day one.

4. Consider Your Venue and Resources.

Does your stage support elaborate sets, or are you working in a more intimate black box space? Do you have access to a full band, or would a show with simpler musical accompaniment be a better fit? The right script works with your resources, not against them.

5. Read, Read, Read.

There is no substitute for reading the script itself. Do not just skim the synopsis. Dive into the dialogue, visualize the staging, and imagine it with your actors. If a script genuinely excites you, that passion will translate to your cast and ultimately to your audience.

Your Next Season Starts Here.

At TLC Scripts, we believe the perfect script is out there waiting for you. By considering these factors, you are not just choosing a play you are building a successful, sustainable future for your community theatre.