267-856-7500
Skip to main content
Pick Our Brains...
< All Topics
Print

The Local Influencer Outreach: Beyond the DM

Posted
Updated

In a community like ours, “Influencers” aren’t people in LA with a million followers. They are the people whose Instagram Stories everyone in town watches to see where to eat or what the local schools are doing. Giving them two tickets is the cheapest, most effective “billboard” you will ever buy.

1. How to Find Your “Local Legends”

Don’t guess. Spend 20 minutes doing the “Digital Stakeout”:

  • The Hashtag Hunt: Search Instagram for #YourTown. See who is posting high-quality photos of local events.

  • The “Tagged” Tab: Look at the “Tagged” photos of the most popular local coffee shops or boutiques. Who is the person tagging them?

  • The Facebook Group “Admin”: The person running the “What’s Happening in [Town]” group is a goldmine. Treat them like royalty.

2. The “Tiered” Outreach Strategy

Don’t send the same message to everyone. Tailor the “Ask” to their vibe:

A. The “Foodie” (Intermission/Concessions focus)

“Hi [Name], we love your coverage of the local restaurant scene! We’re opening [Show Name] at [Theatre Name] and we’ve got some incredible [specific local treat/themed drink] at our concessions. We’d love to host you for a ‘Dinner and a Show’ night (or ‘Snack and a Show’).  Tickets are on us if you’re up for sharing the experience with your followers!”

B. The “Community Advocate” (The ‘Support Local’ focus)

“Hi [Name], thanks for everything you do to keep our community connected. We’re a family-owned shop, and our new production of [Show Name] is all about [Local Theme/Connection]. We’d love to give you two VIP seats for Opening Night. We’re trying to spread the word to locals who love theater.  Would you be open to a shout-out on your Stories?”

3. The “Deliverables” (What to ask for)

Be specific so they don’t have to think. Ask for:

  • One “Coming Soon” Story: A photo of the poster or a snippet of rehearsal.

  • One “Opening Night” Reel/Story: A quick video of them in their seats or at the step-and-repeat.

  • The Link: Ask them to use the “Link Sticker” in Instagram to point directly to your ticket URL.

4. The “Digital Street Team” Pipeline

Don’t reach out to one person and wait by the phone. Treat this like a casting call: you want a full “ensemble” of local voices.

  • Cultivate the Crowd: Reach out to 10–15 local leaders simultaneously.

  • The “Ghosting” Reality: In the influencer world, a “non-answer” isn’t a rejection; it’s just noise. If a local “Power Mom” doesn’t reply to your two-day follow-up, leave the door open, but keep your energy focused on the 5 people who did say yes.

  • Volume Wins: Your goal is a “Saturation Week” where every time a local resident opens Instagram, they see a different person talking about your show. That doesn’t happen by being timid with your outreach list.

5. The “Truth-Bomb” on the Follow-Up

If they don’t answer, don’t take it personally. These people are busy. Send one polite follow-up three days later: “Hey [Name], just checking in! We’re starting to finalize our Opening Night guest list and would still love to have you. Let me know!” If they don’t answer then, move on to the next person on your list.

Tags:
Table of Contents